Giving a portrait this Christmas?

Click here for Christmas gift vouchers

Journal · Pet portraits

Painted pet portrait or a photograph? An honest comparison

Thinking about a painted portrait of your dog? How painting and photography really differ, and when I would tell you to choose the painting.

A woman lying on a timber deck, offering a yellow flower to a boxer dog, in black and white with the flower in colour
A photograph can carry an artist's touch too: black and white, with one flower in colour.

If you have been looking at painted pet portraits, you are not alone. People in Melbourne search for them every week, and some of the work out there is lovely.

I am a photographer, so you might expect me to tell you a photograph is always better. It is not. The two are made in very different ways, and each suits a different situation. Here is the honest version, so you can choose the one that fits your dog and your wall.

How each one is made

Most commissioned pet paintings are made from photographs you send the artist. The painter may never meet your dog. Their skill is in the interpretation: the colours, the background, the style and how closely they follow the likeness.

A photographic portrait is made with your dog in front of the camera. The session runs at your pace and theirs, at home, on the beach or somewhere they love, until the look you know arrives. Afterwards you see every portrait together and choose, rather than waiting on a single image.

When a painting is the better choice

When a photograph is the better choice

A German Shepherd running flat out along a wet beach at dawn
Flat out on the beach at dawn: a moment that only happens in person.

One family had their German Shepherd photographed at home and down at the beach. Their review ends with this:

Thank you Simon and now we have the perfect photos that capture Luna in her purest form.

Adsie B, from a review of Living Image

What each costs

Prices for painted portraits vary widely with the artist, the size and the medium. Ask for the full price, including framing and postage, before you send your photos.

With me, you book a session, see every portrait at the reveal, and then choose your artwork. Artwork begins at $255 for a framed desktop portrait, and the price list shows every size. There is no obligation to buy and no pressure on the day.

Torn between the two? Do them in the right order

A painter works best from a good photograph: sharp eyes, true colour, honest light. If you think you might want a painting one day, a portrait made now gives the artist far better material than a phone photo. It also gives you a photograph of your dog at their best, while they are well and full of life.

Simon Carroll

Simon Carroll has made portraits for more than forty years. He lives in Healesville, in the Yarra Valley, and photographs families and their animals across the Valley and Melbourne.More about Simon

Still looking for a Christmas gift?

Click here for Christmas gift vouchersValid for three years